'Maximizing Shareholder Value': A Theory Run Amok

Clifton Clarke*, Hershey H. Friedman**
*-** Professor of Business, Department of Business Management, Murray Koppelman School of Business, Brooklyn College of the City University, New York, USA.
Periodicity:March - May'2016
DOI : https://doi.org/10.26634/jmgt.10.4.5908

Abstract

The doctrine of Maximizing Shareholder Value (MSV) has been largely viewed as a definitive tool for measuring the performance of the executives of public corporations. Countless business students have been taught that, the sole goal of the firm is MSV, despite the fact that, Jack Welch called this goal the “dumbest idea in the world”. This paper reviews the literature and examines the evolution of this corporate mantra and exposes its potentially disastrous effects on shareholders, employees, customers and the nation. It concludes that, the construct of MSV is a decoy for pursuing higher share price and contends that, corporate profit-making and corporate social responsibility are not incompatible goals. Thus, it proposes that corporations should stop promoting this doctrine as a sacred objective of management and that business schools should discontinue teaching it as the optimum measure of management performance.

Keywords

Maximizing Shareholder Value, Maximizing Profit, Business Ethics, Corporate Social Responsibility.

How to Cite this Article?

Clarke, C., and Friedman, H. H. (2016). 'Maximizing Shareholder Value': A Theory Run Amok. i-manager’s Journal on Management, 10(4), 45-60. https://doi.org/10.26634/jmgt.10.4.5908

References

[1]. Addady, M. (2015). “Peanut executive receives 28- year sentence for deadly salmonella outbreak”. Fortune.com. Retrieved from http://fortune.com/2015/ 09/21/life-sentence-salmonella-outbreak/
[2]. Andersen, E. (2013). “What happens when leaders only care about money?” Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/erikaandersen/2013/12/18/is -greed-good-and-does-it-work-in-business/
[3]. Anderson, S. (2014). “The London whale-sized loopholes in Wall Street pay reform”. Fortune. Retrieved from http://fortune.com/2014/10/27/the-london-whalesized- loopholes-in-wall-street-pay-reform/?utm_source =feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=F eed%3A+fortunebrainstormtech+(Fortune+Brainstorm +Tech)
[4]. Ariely, D. (2008). Predictably Irrational. New York, NY: HarperCollins Publishers.
[5]. Atiyeh, C. & Blackwell, R. (2015). “Massive Takata airbag recall: Everything you need to know, including full list of affected vehicles”. CarandDriver.com. Retrieved from http://blog.caranddriver.com/massive-takataairbag- recall-everything-you-need-to-know-includingfull- list-of-affected-vehicles/
[6]. Ayres, B. (2014). “The two trillion dollar heist: The perversion of inversion”. Huffington Post. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bill-ayres/the-two-trilliondollar- h_b_5736224.html
[7]. Barker, E. (2014). “10 scientific steps to a successful career”. Time.com. Retrieved from http://time.com/ 3103856/10-scientific-steps-to-a-successful-career/
[8]. Berle, A. A. (1931). “Corporate powers as power in trust”. Harvard Law Review, Vol.44, pp.1049.
[9]. Berle, A. & Means, G. (1932). The Modern Corporation and Private Property. New Brunswick, U.S.A. and London: Transaction Publishers, 1991.
[10]. Brooks, A. C. (2014). Capitalism and the Dalai Lama. New York Times, A23. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/18/opinion/capitalismand- the-dalai-lama.html
[11]. Cooper, S. (2014). “Improving workers' safety in global supply chains: The case for a global safety & health management standard”. Retrieved from http://www.asse.org.
[12]. COSO (Committee of Sponsoring Organizations), (2013). Internal Control, Integrated Framework. New York, NY: American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA).
[13]. Crim, D. & Seijts, G. (2006). “What engages employees the most, or the ten c's of employee engagement”. Ivey Business Journal. Retrieved from http://iveybusinessjournal.com/topics/the- workplace/what-engages-employees-the-most or-theten- cs-of-employee-engagement#.U9vh-vldUmM
[14]. Crowe, P. (2015). “The largest takeover of the year is all about avoiding US taxes”. Business Insider. Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/pfizer-allergandeal- tax-inversion-2015-10
[15]. Denning, S. (2011). “The dumbest idea in the world: Maximizing shareholder value”. Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2011/11/28/m aximizing-shareholder-value-the-dumbest-idea-in-theworld/
[16]. Denning, S. (2012). “Can the dumbest idea in the world be saved?” Forbes.com. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2012/11/27/c an-the-shareholder-value-theory-be-mended/
[17]. Denning, S. (2013). “The origin of 'the world's dumbest idea': Milton Friedman”. Forbes.com. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/stevedenning/2013/06/26/th e-origin-of-the-worlds-dumbest-idea-milton-friedman/
[18]. Dodd, M. E. (1932). “For whom are corporate managers trustees?” Harvard Law Review, Vol.45, pp.1148.
[19]. Duhaime (2016). “Corporation definition”. Duhaime's Law Dictionary. Retrieved from http://www.duhaime.org/ LegalDictionary/C/Corporation.aspx
[20]. Etzioni, A. (2002, August 4). “When it comes to ethics, b-schools get an 'F'”. Washington Post. B4. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A38323- 2002Aug2
[21]. Fried, J. M. (2008). “Option backdating and its implications”. Washington and Lee Law Review, Vol.65, pp.853-886. Retrieved from http://www.law.harvard.edu/ faculty/jfried/option_backdating_and_its_ implications.pdf
[22]. Friedman, H. H., Edris, S., & Friedman, L. W. (2015). “ Is greed good? Learning business ethics from King Leopold II, mass murderer ”. SSRN. Retrieved from SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2617553 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2617553
[23]. Friedman, H. H.& Friedman, L. W. (2014). “Why spirituality belongs in the business curriculum”. SSRN.com. Retrieved from SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2408224 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2408224
[24]. Friedman, H. H.& Lewis, B. J. (2014). “A new kind of CEO for the global information age”. Business Quest. Retrieved from http://www.westga.edu/~bquest/2014/ ceo2014.pdf
[25]. Friedman, H. H., Lynch, J. A.& Herskovitz, P. J. (2013). “Using a comprehensive multi-modal approach to teach values and ethics”. SS International Journal of Business and Management Research, Vol.3(2), pp.124-143. Retrieved from SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2395634
[26]. Friedman, M. (1970). “The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits”. New York Times Magazine, 122-124. Retrieved from http://www.colorado.edu/ studentgroups/libertarians/issues/friedman-soc-respbusiness. html
[27]. Fry, L. W. (2003). “Toward a theory of spiritual leadership”. Leadership Quarterly, Vol.14, pp.693-727.
[28]. Gardiner, B. (2010). “Emphasis on ethics”. Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from http://online.wsj.com/article/ SB10001424052702304168004575178410786321340.h tml
[29]. Goudreau, J. (2015). “Google HR boss explains the only 2 ways to keep your best people from quitting”. Business Insider. Retrieved from http://www.businessinsider.com/google-laszlo-bock-howto- retain-employees-2015-4
[30]. Grady, D. (2014). “Ebola vaccine, ready for test sat on sideline”. New York Times, A1, A18.
[31]. Greenfield, K. (2015). “If corporations are people, they should act like it”. Atlantic. Retrieved from http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/02/ifcorporations- are-people-they-should-act-like-it/385034/
[32]. Gross, R. & Holland, B. (2011). “Corporate social responsibility and employee engagement: Making the connection”. Retrieved from http://www.mandrake.ca/ bill/ images/corporate_responsibility_white_paper.pdf
[33]. Guthrie, D. (2011). Business ethics and social responsibility [Video file]. Retrieved from http://business.gwu.edu/dean/video/
[34]. Harris, G. (2013). “Bangladeshi factory owners charged in fire that killed 112”. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2013/12/23/world/asis/banglad eshi-factory-owners-charged-in-fatal-fire.h...
[35]. Hayat, U. (2014). “Shareholder value maximization: The world's dumbest idea?” European Investment Conference. Retrieved from http://eic.cfainstitute.org/ 2014/10/23/shareholder-value-maximization-thedumbest- idea-in-the-world/
[36]. Hazelton, J. (2005). “The amorality of public corporations”. Essays in Philosophy, Vol.6(2), Article 6. Retrieved from http://commons.pacificu.edu/cgi/ viewcontent.cgi? article=1209&context=eip
[37]. Holland, K. (2009). “Is it time to retrain b-schools?” New York Times, Sunday Business, 1-2.
[38]. Howard, G. S. (1997). “The tragedy of maximization”. Ecopsychology Online. Retrieved from http://ecopsychology.athabascau.ca/1097/index.htm# politics
[39]. Jensen, M. C.& Meckling, W. H., (1976). “Theory of the firm: Managerial behavior, agency costs and ownership structure”. Journal of Financial Economics, Vol.3(4). Retrieved from http://ssrn.com/abstract=94043 or http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.94043
[40]. Karakas, F. (2010). “Spirituality and performance in organizations: A literature review”. Journal of Business Ethics, Vol.94(1), pp.89-106.
[41]. Korn, M. (2013). “Does an 'A' in ethics have any value?” Wall Street Journal. B4.
[42]. Korten, D. C. (2000). The Post-corporate World, Life after Capitalism. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc. and West Hartford, CT: Kumarian Press, Inc.
[43]. Lazonick, B. (2014). “The myth of maximizing shareholder value”. Retrieved from http://ineteconomics. org/institute-blog/myth-maximizing-shareholder-value
[44]. Leggett, C. (1999). “The Ford Pinto case: The valuation of life as it applies to the negligence-efficiency argument ”. Retrieved from https://users.wfu.edu/ palmitar/Law& Valuation/Papers/1999/Leggett-pinto.html
[45]. López-Pérez, R. & Spiegelman, E. (2012). “Do economists lie more?” Working Paper: Universidad Autonoma. Retrieved from http://www.uam.es/ departamentos/economicas/analecon/especifica/mim eo/wp20124.pdf
[46]. Mangan, K. (2006). “Agents of fortune”. Chronicle of Higher Education, A14-A16.
[47]. McGhee, P., & Grant, P. (2008). “Spirituality and ethical behavior in the workplace: Wishful thinking or authentic reality”. Electronic Journal of Business Ethics and Organization Studies, Vol.13(2), pp.61-69.
[48]. Mediaspin (2012). Milton Friedman on capitalism and greed! [Video File]. Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=alP0WiL2P0g
[49]. Morgenson, G. (2015). Valeant's fantastic(al) numbers. New York Times, BU1, Bu6.
[50]. Nocera, J. (2012). “Down with shareholder value”. New York Times. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/ 2012/08/11/opinion/nocera-down-with-shareholdervalue. html
[51]. Nocera, J. (2014). “Carl Icahn's bad advice”. New York Times, A21.
[52]. O'Donnell, J. (2013). “Survey: Most would boycott irresponsible company”. USA Today. Retrieved from http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/business/2013/05 /21/consumers-boycott-companies-bad-behavior-gapprotests/ 2343619/
[53]. Pinkovsky, M. & Sala-i-Martin, X. (2010). “Parametric estimations of the world distribution of income”. VOX – Centre for Economic Policy Research. Retrieved from http://www.voxeu.org/article/parametric-estimationsworld- distribution-income
[54]. Pitelis, C. (2002). “On economics and business ethics”. Business Ethics: A European Review, Vol.11(2), pp.111-118.
[55]. Pollack, A.&Tavernise, S. (2015). “A drug company's price tactics pinch insurers and consumers”. New York Times, A1, B2.
[56]. Porter, M. D. & Kramer, M. R. (2006). “Strategy and society: The link between competitive advantage and corporate social responsibility”. Harvard Business Review, pp.1-14.
[57]. Rappaport, A. (2006). “Ten ways to create shareholder value”. Harvard Business Review. Retrieved from https://hbr.org/2006/09/ten-ways-to-createshareholder- value
[58]. Reclaim Democracy, (2016). “Our hidden history of corporations in the United States”. Retrieved from http://reclaimdemocracy.org/corporate-accountabilityhistory- corporations-us/
[59]. Rehman, Z., Walsh, D., & Massod, S. (2012). “More than 300 killed in Pakistani factory fires”. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/13/world/asia/hundred s-die-in-factory-fires-in-pakistan.html?_r=0
[60]. Rhodes, K.(2006). “Six components of a model for workplace spirituality ”. Graziadio Business Report, Vol.9(2), Retrievedfrom http://gbr.pepperdine.edu/062/ workplace.html.
[61]. Sahadi, J. (2014). “ Treasury acts to stop overseas tax 'inversions'”. CNN Money. Retrieved from http://money.cnn.com/2014/09/22/news/economy/treas ury-inversions/
[62]. Sanghoee, S. (2014). “Why shareholder value should not be the only goal of public companies”. Time. Retrieved from http://time.com/4121/why-shareholderv alue-should-not-be-the-only-goal-of-public- companies/
[63]. Smith, Y. (2014). “The myth of maximizing shareholder value”. Naked Capitalism. Retrieved from http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2014/01/mythaximizing- shareholder-value.html
[64]. Stout, H. (2014). “Class-action case accuses G.M. of neglect beyond ignition switch”. New York Times, B1, B6.
[65]. Stout, L. (2012). The Shareholder Value Myth: How Putting Shareholders First Harms Investors, Corporations and the Public. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Koehler Publishers, Inc.
[66]. Tamayo de-Guzman, H. (2013). “The role of accountants in effective governance”. PICPA. Retrieved from http://www.picpa.com.ph/PICPA/media/Technical Materials/AWC_2013/(regulators-day)-Present.The-Roleof- Accountants-in-Effective-Governance.pdf
[67]. The Institute of Internal Auditors, (2012). “Ethical dilemmas ”. To ne at the To p. Retrieved from https://na.theiia.org/periodicals/Public%20Documents/T aT_April_2012.pdf
[68]. Wartzman, R. (2013). “The long view: Why “maximizing shareholder value” is on its way out”. Retrieved from http://business.time.com/2013/09/25/thelong- view-why-maximizing-shareholder-value-is-on-itsway- out/
[69]. White, M. (2012). The Great Big Book of Horrible Things. New York, NY: W. W. Norton & Company
[70]. Yang, J. L. (2013). “Maximizing shareholder value: The goal that changed corporate America”. Washington Post. Retrieved from http://www.washingtonpost. com/business/economy/maximizing-shareholder-valuethe- goal-that-changed-corporate-america/2013/08/26/ 26e9ca8e-ed74-11e2-9008-61e94a7ea20d_story.html
[71]. Yau, S., & Brutoco, R. S. (2012). “From the current business paradigm to the second renaissance”. World Business Academy. Retrieved from http://worldbusiness. org/from-the-current-business-paradigm-to-the-secondrenaissance/
[72]. Zhang, S. (2015). “New study links VW's emissions cheating to 60 early deaths”. Wired.com. Retrieved from http://www.wired.com/2015/10/new-study-links-vwsemissions- cheating-59-deaths/
If you have access to this article please login to view the article or kindly login to purchase the article

Purchase Instant Access

Single Article

North Americas,UK,
Middle East,Europe
India Rest of world
USD EUR INR USD-ROW
Online 15 15

Options for accessing this content:
  • If you would like institutional access to this content, please recommend the title to your librarian.
    Library Recommendation Form
  • If you already have i-manager's user account: Login above and proceed to purchase the article.
  • New Users: Please register, then proceed to purchase the article.