Efficient Market: Reaction to the Announcements of Tracking Stocks in the USA

0*
*Professor,Department of Management and Information Systems ,Montclair State University ,NJ,USA.
Periodicity:December - February'2008
DOI : https://doi.org/10.26634/jmgt.2.3.334

Abstract

A tracking stock, also known as targeted stock or letter stock, is issued as a new class of common stock that represents the financial performance of a specific division or subsidiary of the parent company. General Motors pioneered the use of tracking stock with its acquisition of Electronic Data Systems in 1984 and Hughes Electronics in 1985. Between 1984 and 1998, over forty tracking stocks have been issued or have been under consideration. Since 1998 not only many companies have not issued tracking stocks but many parent companies have also withdrawn most of what they issued in prior years.  However, there is a renewed interest in using this tool.  EMC announced an IPO plan in February, 2007 for one of its division, VMware.

Prior studies have shown that public announcements of issuing tracking-stocks or spin-offs tend to increase the price of the parent company's stock by 2% to 3%. The study reported in this paper shows that there is an upward trend in excess returns starting 45 days before the announcement date and spiking on the announcement date. Over the period of 45 days preceding the announcement, the value of the portfolio goes up on average roughly by 5% over the market. There is almost a jump of 6% on the day of the announcement. Then, in the next 45 days after the announcement, most of the value is gone even though not all is lost - the portfolio still maintains approximately 2% gain over the market. However, as indicated by the hypothesis testing, the value is not statistically significant. This phenomenon - sustaining some value gain (2% for our portfolio) can be seen as an evidence of a value creation.

Keywords

How to Cite this Article?

Ram B. Misra (2008). Efficient Market: Reaction to the Announcements of Tracking Stocks in the USA. i-manager’s Journal on Management, 2(3), 16-28. https://doi.org/10.26634/jmgt.2.3.334

References

[I ]. Allen, J. , and McConnell, J, (I 998), Equity Carve-outs and Managerial Discretion,Journa/ of Finance, February,
[2]. AnsLInger, R L., Klepper, S. J., Subramaniam, S. (1999), Breaking Up Is Good To Do: Restructuring Through Spin-offs, Equity Carve-outs And Tracking Stocks Can Create Shareholder Value, The McKlnsey Quarterly, Winter.
[3]. Billet, M. and Mower, D.C. (2000), Diversification and the Value of Internal Capital Markets: The Case of Tracking Stocks, Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol, 24, 1457- 1490.
[4]. Billet, M. and Vijh, A. M. (2000), Long-Term Return from Tracking Stocks, Journal of Financial Research, VoL 27, Issue 4, December~ ly.
[5]. Bonham , R . ( I 9 9 9) , Track Stars, Journal of Accountancy, Ju
[6]. Callahan, S. (1999), IPO Brings Mixed News For Ziff- Davis, Business Marketlng, April 1 .
[7]. Chemmanur, T. J. and Paeglis, I. (2001), Why issue Tracking Stocks? insights from a Comparison with Spin-offs and Carve-outs, Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, Vol. 14, Issue
[8]. Clayton, M. J. and Gian, Y. (2004), Wealth Gains from Tracking Stocks: Long-Run Performance and Ex-Date Returns, Flnancial Management, Voi~ 33, Iss, 3, Autumn~
[9]. Cowen, S. O. (1999), Public Market Transactions for Repackaging Corporate Assets, Tracking Stock, Carve- Outs, Spin-Offs and Split-Offs, Equity Capltal Markets, September,
[10]. Coy R (1999), Tracking Stocks Are Accidents Waiting To Happen, Business Week, August 2.
[I I ]. D'Souza, and Jacob, John (2000), Why Firms issue Targeted Stocks, Journal of Financial Economics, VoL 56, 459-483.
[I 2]. Elder, J. and Westra, R (2000), The Reaction of Security Prices to Tracking Stock Announcements, Journa/ of Economicsand Flnance, Vol. 24, No. 1, Spring
[I 3]. Elder, J, Jain, R K. and Kim, J. C. (2005), Do Tracking Stocks Reduce Information Asymmetries? An Analysis of Liquidity and Adverse Selection, Journal of Financial Research, Vol 22, Iss, 2. , June.
[14]. Fama, C.F. , Fisher, L., Jensen, M. , and Roll, R. (19 69), The Adjustment of Stock Prices to New Information, internationalEconomlcRevlew, February.
[I 5]. Frank, K. E. (2001), Making Sense of Spin-offs, Tracking Stock and Equity Carve-outs, Strategic Flnance, December.
[16]. Harper, J. T. and Madure, J. (2002), Sources of Hidden Value and Risk within Tracking Stock, Financial Management, Vol, 31, Iss. 3, Autumn,
[I 7]. Mite, G . L. and Owers, J. E., (1983), Security Price Reactions Around Corporate Spin-Off Announcements, Journal of Financial Economics, VoL 12, 409-436 .
[I 8]. Hougen, R. A. (2001), Modern Investment Theory, Prentice Hali, Fifth Edition, Saddle River, NJ
[I 9]. Kedrosky , R (I 999), The Delusion Of Tracking Stocks: Treating A Division As A Separafe Company Raises Thorny Issues, National Post, March 31
[20]. Logue, D. E., Sfeword J. K, Wolsh, J. R (1996), Rearranging Residual Claims: A Case for Targeted Sfock, Financial Management, Vol. 25, 43-61, Spring.
[2 I ]. Loshinsky, A. (2007), EMC Offers A Slice of Ifs Surging Software Unit Fortune, June I I .
[22]. Michoely, R. ond Show, W (1995), The Choice of Going Public: Spinoff's vs. Carveoufs, Flnanciai Management, Autumn.
[23]. Peorson, M. (1998), Spin-offs: Breaking Up Is Hard To Do, Journai of Business Strategy, July-August.
[24]. Ross, S.A., Wesferfield, R. W., ond Joffe, J. (2008), Corporate Finance, McGraw-Hi\\ Irwin Pubiications, 81h Edltion.
[25]. Shleifer A. (2000), Inefficient Markets: An Infroduction fo Behavioral Finance, O.xford: Oxford Uni'versily Press.
[26]. Singol, V. (2004), Beyond the Random Walk, New York: Oxford Uni`versity Press.
[27]. Sfephen, N. (1995), Creating Value wifh Targeted Stock, Euromoney, Publications PLC, June.
[28]. Syre, S, ond Sfein, C. (I 999), Genzyme Tracking Stocks Are Off Track On Returns, Boston Giobe, June 24.
[29]. Tessler, J. (I 999), Firms Turn to Tracking Stocks To UnlockValue of Web Units, DowJonesNewswires, July I 2,
If you have access to this article please login to view the article or kindly login to purchase the article

Purchase Instant Access

Single Article

North Americas,UK,
Middle East,Europe
India Rest of world
USD EUR INR USD-ROW
Online 15 15

Options for accessing this content:
  • If you would like institutional access to this content, please recommend the title to your librarian.
    Library Recommendation Form
  • If you already have i-manager's user account: Login above and proceed to purchase the article.
  • New Users: Please register, then proceed to purchase the article.