Cultural Values and Tax Accounting Decisions

Stephen J.J. McGuire*, David Hossain**, Edward Lance Monsour***
*Associate Professor ,Management and Director of the Enterpreneurship Institute ,California ,State University ,Los Angels.
**,*** Assistant Professor ,Accounting and Taxation ,California State University Los Angels
Periodicity:September - November'2008
DOI : https://doi.org/10.26634/jmgt.3.2.263

Abstract

We examined ethically-charged business and tax accounting decisions made by 598 Arab, Chinese, Latin American, Iranian, American, and Vietnamese students. Respondents indicated decisions on 11 situations, and separately provided data on their cultural values, education, work and managerial experience. Our purpose was to test hypotheses that individual-level cultural values, education and experience, and the interaction of values and education/ experience affected the decisions people made. In other words, shed light on the “why” behind differences in intentions. Business managers often face challenging situations that require ethical reasoning. Accountants preparing tax statements are frequently required to make decisions about ambiguous situations. In the U.S, tax preparers are expected to follow the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants' standards of ethical tax practice. While the laws for tax preparation are of course country specific, common dilemmas are faced by tax accountants worldwide, such as dealing with estimates and correcting errors unlikely to be caught by authorities. Result indicate that six cultural values, Being orientation, Determinism, Power Distance, Uncertainty Avoidance, Collectivism, and Facework were significant predictors of business and tax accounting decisions in 11 out of 11 scenarios, when controlling for age and gender. In most cases, we failed to find that work experience, years of study, accountancy studies, or managerial experience were significant predictors. However, we did find that the interaction of education and experience with cultural values moderated the relationship between the six cultural values and business and tax accounting decisions.

Keywords

Culture, Values, Ethics, Decisions, Tax, International, Arab Countries, China, Iran, Latin America, Vietnam, USA, Questionnaire

How to Cite this Article?

Stephen J.J. McGuire, David Hossain and Edward Lance Monsour (2008). Cultural Values and Tax Accounting Decisions. i-manager’s Journal on Management, 3(2), 39-69. https://doi.org/10.26634/jmgt.3.2.263

References

( I ). R. Abratt, D. NeI & N.S. Higgs C I 992). An examination of the ethical beliefs of managers using selected scenarios in a cross-cultural environment, Journal of BusinessEthics, 11,pp. 29-.35.
(2). N.J. Adler, (2002). /nternoHonol dlmenslon of organizationalbehavlo 4th Ed. Cincinnati, OH: South Western.
(3). I. Ajzen, 1. & M. Flshbein,( I 980). Understondlng ottltudes ond predlctlng soclol behovlor. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
(4). RD. Allison, C I 999). Logistic regresslon using the SAS system. SAS Institute.
(5). B.H. Beach, I 9 75). Expert judgment about uncertainty: Bayesian decision making in realistic setting, Orgonlzotlonol Behovlor ond Humon Performonce, 14, pp. I 0-59 .
(6). H. Becker & D.J. Fritzsche C I 987). A comparison of the ethicol behovior of Americon, French ond Germon monogers, Columb\a Journal of World Buslness, 22.'4), pp.87-95.
(7). R. Benedict ( I 946). Patterns of culture, New York: Mentor.
(8). R.H.Bennett, III. ( I 999). The relotive effects of situotionol proctices ond culturolly influenced volues/ beliefs on work ottitudes, Internatlonal Journal of CommerceandManagement, 9, pp.84- I 02.
(9).D. Bobek, R. Roberts & J.T. Sweeny, (2007). The socio| norms of tox complionce: Evidence from Austrolio, Singopore, ond the United Stoles, Journal of Buslness Ethics, 74, pp.49-64.
(10). M.H. Bond & G. Hofstede C I 989). The Gosh volue of Confucion volues, Human Systems Management, 8, pp. I 95-200.
( I I ). N. Brenner, N. & S.J.J. McGuire, (2003). Toword o model of culturol volues ond norms: o confirmotory foctor onolysis, Proceed\ngs of the /8 Annual Washlngton Consortlum of Schools of Buslness Research Forum, Woshington,DC.
( I 2). G.F. Covonough , D.J. Moberg & M. Velosquez, C I 98 I ). The ethics of orgonizotionol politics, Academy of ManagementRevlew, 6, pp.363-374.
( I 3). J. Cherry, M. Lee & C.S. Chien, (2003). A cross- culturol opplicotion of o theoreticol model of business ethics: Bridging the gop between theory ond doto, Journal of BusinessEthics, 44, pp. 359-"376 .
( I 4) . M . C hi , P Felt ovich & R. GI Os er. ( I 9 8 I ) . Cotegorizotion ond representotion of physics problems by experts ond novices, Cognitive Sclence, 5: pp. 121 - I 52.
(15). J. Cohen & R Cohen. C I 983). Applied multlple regresslon analyses for the behavloral sclences, 2 ed. Hillside, NJ: Erlboum.
( I 6). J.R. Cohen, L.W. Pont , & D.J. Shorp, C I 995). An explorotory exominotion of internotionol differences in ouditors' ethicol perceptions, Behdvioral Research In Accountlng, 7, pp.37-64
( I 7). M. Csikszentmiholyi, C I 996) . CreaHvity: F/ow and the psychology of dlscovery and Inventlon, New York: HorperCollins.
( I 8). K. Cyrioc & R. Dhormoroj C I 984). MochioveHionism in Indion monogement, Journal of Buslness Ethics, 13, pp. 28 I -286 .
( I 9). C. Cruz, , E. Monsour & R. Elios, (2006). Accounting students' likelihood of complionce with tox preporotion stondords, Journal of Buslness Strategles, 23, pp. I 55- I 66.
(20). R Dovis & S. Worthington. C I 993). Cooperotive volues: Chonge ond continuity in copitol occumulotion, the cose of the British Cooperotive Bonk, Journal of BuslnessEthics, 12, pp. 849-"860.
(2 I ). R Dorfmon. & J. Howell. ( I 988). Dimensions of notionol culture ond effective leodership potterns: Hofstede revisited, in R.N. Former & E.G. McGoun (Eds.), Aavances in Internatlonal comparaHve management Cpp. I 27- I 50). Greenwich, CT: JAI Press.
(22). A.J. Dubinsky, M.A. Jolson, M. Kotobe & C.U. Lim. ( I 99 I ) . A cross-notionol investigotion of industriol solespeople's ethicol perspectives, Journal of internatlonal Buslness Studies, Fourth Quorter, pp.651- 670.<
(23). RC . Eorley. ( I 99 7). Face, harmony and soclal structure.' An analysis of organlzatlonal behavior across cultures, NewYork: Oxford University Press.
(24). RC . Eorley. C I 999). Ploying follow the leoder: Stotus- determining trolls in relotion to collective efficocy ocross cultures, Organlzatlonal Behavlor and Human Declslon Processes, 80, pp. I 92-2 I 2 .
(25). R. Fridoy. ( I 989). Controsts in discussion behoviors of Germon ond Americon Monogers, /nternaHonal Journal of intercultural Relatlons, 13, pp. 429-445.
(26). D.J. Fritzsche & H. Becker. (1984). Linking monogement behovior to ethicol philosophy on empiricol investigotion, Academy of Management Journal, 27, pp. I 66- I 75 .
(27). C.A. Gobrielidis, W.G. Stephon, O. Yborro,V.M. Dos Sontos Peorson & L. Villorreol (1997). Preferred styles of conflict resolution: Mexico ond the United Stoles, Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 28 , pp.66 I -677.
(28). M.A. Geletkanycz, (1997). The salience of culture's consequences: The effects of cultural values on top executive commitment to the status quo, Strateglc ManagementJournal, 18, pp.615-634.
(29). J. Goodwin & D. Goodwin, (1999) . Ethical judgments across cultures: A comparison between business students from Malaysia and New Zealand, Journal of Buslness Ethics, 18, pp. 267-281 .
(30). W.B. Gudykunst, (1997). Cultural variability in communication, Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology, 24, pp.327-'348.
(3 I ). J.L. Guerrero-Cusumano, & S. McGuire. (2001, "Culture, Economic Creativity and Innovation," Proceedlngs of the 2001 /nternatlonal Research MAAOE Conference (Multinational Alliance for the Advancement of Organizational Excellence), Paris.
(32). A. Haas. (2005). Now is the time for ethics in education, The CPAJournal, 75 (6): pp. 66-68.
(33). J.F. Hair, Jr., R. Anderson, R. Tatham, & W. Black, (1995). Multlvarlate data analysis, 4th Ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
(34). D.C. Hambrick, S. Conney Davison, S.A. Snell, & C.C. Snow (1998). When groups consist of multiple nationalities: Towards a new understanding of the implications, Organlzatlon Studies, 19, pp.1 81-205.
(35). G. Hofstede, (1980). Culture's consequences.' international dlfferences In work-related values, Beverly Hills: Sage.
(36). G. Hofstede, (2001). Culture's consequences.' Comparlng values, behavlors, Institutions, and organlzatlons acrossnatlons. London: Sage.
(37). G. Hofstede & M.H. Bond, (1988). The Confucius connection: From cultural roots to economic growth, OrganlzaHonal Dynamics 16(4), pp.4-21 .
(38). M. Hoppe, (1990). A comparative study of country elites: International differences in work-.related values and learning and their implications for management training and development, Doctoral Dissertation, University of North Carolinaat Chapel Hill.
(39). M.K Hui, Au, K & H. Fock, (2004). Empowerment effects across cultures, Journal of /nternatlonal Buslness Studies,35, pp.46-55.
(40). E.C. Hume, E.R. Larkins & G. lyer. (1999). On compliance with ethical standards in tax preparation, Journal of BuslnessEthics, 18: pp. 229-238.
(4 I ). E.C. Hume. & A. Smith. (2006). Cultural and gender differences in the ethical beliefs of accountants, Journa/ of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory /ssues, 9(1/2).. pp.1 7-30 .
(42). D.Izraeli, (1988). Ethical beliefs and behavior of managers: A cross-cultural perspective, Journa/ of BuslnessEthlcs7, pp.263-271
(43). E.F. Jackofsky,.J.W. Slocum & S.J. McQuaid. (1988). Cultural values and the CEO: Alluring companions? Academy of Management Executlve, 11(1), pp. 39-49.
[44]. Jaques, E. (1952). The changlng culture of a factory. NewYork: Dryden Press.
(45). B. Kedia, R.T. Keller & S.D. Julian, (1992). Dimensions of national culture and the productivity of R&D units, Journal of High Technology Management Research, 3: pp.1-18.
(46). 8.1. Kirkman & D. Shapiro. (1997). The impact of cultural values on employee resistance to teams: Toward a model of globalized self-managing work team effectiveness, Academy of Management Revlew, 22, pp.730-757.
(47). F. Kluckhohn & F.R. Strodtbeck. (1961). Varlatlons In value orlentatlons, Westport, CT: Greenwood.
(48). M.A. Kolosov, D.W. Martin & J.H. Peterson. (1993). Ethics and behavior on the Russian Commodity Exchange, Journal of BuslnessEthlcs 12, pp. 741-744.
(49). C.C Langlois, & 8.8. Schlegelmilch, (1990). Do corporate codes of ethics reflect national character? Evidence from Europe and the United States, Journal of internatlonal Buslness 1O, pp. 951 -960.
(50). A. Laurent. (1983). The cultural diversity of western conceptions of management, /nternaHonal Studies In Management and Organlzatlon, 13, pp. 75-96.
(5 I ). V.A. Lefebvre. (1982). A/gebra of consclence.' A comparatlve analysis of Western and Sovlet ethlcal systems, Boston: D. Reidel.
(52). T. Lenartowicz & J.R Johnson. (2003). A Cross- national assessment of the values of Latin American managers: Contrasting hues or shades of gray?Journa/ of internatlonal BuslnessStudl`es, 34, pp.266.275.
(53). K Leung. ( I 987). Some determinants of reactions to procedural models for conflict resolution: A cross-national study, Journal of Personallty and Soclal Psychology, 53, pp.898-9 I 0.
(54). K. Leung & A.E. Lind. C I 986). Procedural justice and culture: Effects of culture, gender, and investigator status on procedural preference, Journal of Personallty and Soclal Psychology, 50, pp. I I 34- I I 40.
(55). B. Libby, & V. Agnello. (2000). Ethical decision making and the law, Journal of Buslness Ethics, 26, pp.223-232.
(56). S. McGuire, L. Fok & K Kwong. (2006). A comparative study of international cultural and ethical values: Preliminary findings and research agenda, /nternatlonal Journal of Management Theory and Practlces, 7 ( I ).
(57). S. McGuire, K Groves, E. Drost, & K Kwong. (2007). What drives entrepreneurs? Types and antecedents of entrepreneurial intent, working paper, California State University, Los Angeles, July 29 .
(58). S. McGuire, & C. Paunescu. (2006). Cultural values and business decisions: Preliminary results of a mulfi- country research project, Proceedlngs of the 2006 /nternatlonal Conference of Knowledge Management, Vol. X, pp. 79-"88, Bucharest.
(59). A. Mitchell, T. Puxty, R Sikka & H. Willmott. C I 994). Ethical statements as smokescreens for sectional interests: The case of the U.K accountancy profession, Journal of BuslnessEthlcs 13 , pp. 39-5 I .
(60). M. Morris, R.A. Avila & J. Allen. C I 993). Individualism and the modern corporation: Implications for innovation and entrepreneurship, Journal of Management, 19, pp.595-6 I 2.
(6 I ). J.K Mullin Marta, A. Singhapakdi, A. Attic & S.J. Vifell. (2004). Some important factors underlying ethical decisions of middle-eastern marketers, /nternatlonal Marketlng Revlew, 21, pp.53- 67.
(62). J.K Mullin Marta, A. Attic, A. Singhapakdi & N. Atteya, (2003). A comparison of ethical perceptions and moral philosophies of American and Egyptian business students, Teachlng BuslnessEthics, 7, pp. I - 20.
(63). K Newman, & S. Nollen, C I 996) . Culture and congruence: The fit between management practices and national culture, Journal of /nternatlonal Buslness Studies, 27, pp. 753-779 .
(64). R. Nisbett, D.Krantz, C. Jepson & Z. Kunda. (1983). The use of statistical heuristics in everyday inductive reasoning, Psycho/og/ca/Revlew, 90, pp.339-63 .
(65) . J. G . Oetzel , C I 9 9 8 ) . Explaining individual communication processes in homogeneous and heterogeneous groups through individualism- collectivism and self-construal, Human Communication research,25, pp.202-224.
(66). N. O'Fallon & K Butterfield (2005). A review of the empirical ethical decision-making literature: I 996-2003, Journal of BuslnessEthics, 59, pp.375-4 I 4.
(67). S. Perkins & R. Rao. C I 990). The role of experience in information use and decision making, Journal of Marketlng Research, 27, pp. I - I 0.
(68). S.R. Premeaux & R.W. Mondy. C I 993). Linking management behavior to ethical philosophy, Journal of Buslness Ethics, 12 , pp.349-"357.
(69). E.H. Schein, (1985). Organlzatlonal culture and leadershlp, San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
(70). F.L. Schmidt, J.E. Hunter & M.A. McDaniel. (1988). Job experience correlates of job performance, Journal of Appllied Psychology, 73 , pp. 327-"330.
(7 I ). F.L. Schmidt, J.E. Hunter, & A.M. Outerbridge. (1986). Impact of job experience and ability on job knowledge, work sample performance, and supervisory ratings of job performance, Journal of Applied Psychology, 71, pp.432-439.
(72). S.H. Schwartz. C I 990). Individualism collectivism: Critique and proposed refinements, Journal of Cross- Cultural Psychology, 24, pp.3 I 9-"343.
(73). S. Shane (1992) . Why do some societies invent more than others?Journa/ of Buslness Venturlng, 7, pp. 29-46. .
(74). S. Shone( I 993) Cultural influences on national rates of innovation, Journa/ of Business Venturing, B, pp.59-73
(75). S. Shone( I 995). Uncertainty avoidance and the preference for innovation championing roles, Journal of International BusinessStudies, 26 , pp.47-68.
(76). S. Shone, S. Venkotoromon & I.Mocmillon. C I 995). Cultural dif ferenc es in innovation championing strategies, Journal of Management, 21, pp.93 I -952.
(77). S. Shone A. Singhopokdi, Mullin Morto, C.R Roo & M. Cicic, (2001). Is cross-cultural similarity an indicator of similar marketing ethics? Journa/ of Business Ethics, 32 ,pp. 55-68.
(78). A. Smith & E.C. Hume. (2005). Linking culture and ethics: A comparison of accountants' ethical belief systems in the individualism/collectivism and power distance contexts, Journal of Business Ethics, 62: pp. 209- 220.
(79) M. Sondergoord, C I 994). Hofstede's consequences: A study of reviews, citations and replications, Organization Studies, 15,pp. 447-456.
(80). G. Soutor, M.M. McNeil & C. Molster. (1994). The impact of the work environment on ethical decision- making: Some Australian evidence, Journal of Business Ethics 13, pp. 327-"340.
(8 I ). S. TIng-Toomey. ( I 988). Intercultural conflict styles: A face-negotiation theory, in Y.Y. Kim & Gudykunst, W. (Eds.), Theories in intercultural communication, Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
(82). M. Tlxier. (1996). Management styles across Western European cultures, in S.M. Puffer (Ed.), Management across cultures (pp. 260-272, Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
(83). H.C. Triondis. (1995). Individualism and collectivism, Boulder, CO: Westview.
(84) F. Trompenoors, C I 993). Riding the waves of culture.' Understanding diversity in global business. Burr Ridge, IL: Irwin. 8.
(85). J. Tsolikis,. & O. Nwochukw. C I 991). A comparison of Nigerian to American views of bribery and extortion in international commerce, Journal of Business Ethics 1O, pp.85-9
86) J. Tsolikis & M.S. LoTour. (1995). Bribery and extortion in international business: Ethical perceptions of Greeks compared to Americans, Journal of Business Ethics 14, pp.249-264.
87) R. Tung, C I 996). Managing in Asia: Cross cultural dimensions, in R Joynf & M. Warner (Eds.), Managing across cultures (pp. 233-245), London: International Thompson.
(88). R Ulrich & U. Thielemonn. ( I 993). How do managers think about market economies and morality? Empirical enquiries into business-ethical thinking patterns, Journa/ of BusinessEthics, 12 , pp. 879-"898.
(89). R.J.Volkemo & M.T.L. Floury, (2002). Alternative negotiating conditions and the choice of negotiation tactics: A cross-cultural comparison, Journal of Business Ethics, 36, pp. 38 I -"398.
(90). LL. Whitcomb, C.8. Erdener, & C.Li C I 998) . Business ethical values in China and the U.S., Journal of Business Ethics, 17, pp.839-"852.
(91). L. Wlllioms & S. McGuire, (2008). Economic creativity and innovation implementation : The entrepreneurial drivers of growth ? Evidence from 63 countries, Small BusinessEconomics, published online: I 5 October 2008 .
(92). B. Yoo & N. Donthu. (2002). The effects of marketing education and individual cultural values on marketing ethics of students, Journal of Marketing Education, 24, 92-104.
If you have access to this article please login to view the article or kindly login to purchase the article

Purchase Instant Access

Single Article

North Americas,UK,
Middle East,Europe
India Rest of world
USD EUR INR USD-ROW
Online 15 15

Options for accessing this content:
  • If you would like institutional access to this content, please recommend the title to your librarian.
    Library Recommendation Form
  • If you already have i-manager's user account: Login above and proceed to purchase the article.
  • New Users: Please register, then proceed to purchase the article.