Improving Energy Efficiency In Partial Loaded Induction Motor- Using Power Electronic Controllers

C Thanga Raj  
PSN College of Engineering and Technology, Tirunelveli, India

Abstract

The Indian power sector more than tripled its installed capacity from 30 GW in 1981 to over 110 GW in 2003-04; however the country is still plagued by severe peaking and energy shortages. These shortages are exacerbated by inefficiencies in power generation, distribution and end use system. The efficiencies in the end use system are due to irrational tariffs, technological obsolescence of industrial equipment, and lack of awareness, a nascent energy service industry and inadequate policy drivers. This paper presents an analysis of partial loaded induction motor with energy efficiency.

Attributes under investigations include,

1) effect of using oversize induction motor

2) voltage regulators

3) experimental study in 1 HP motor

4) case study at 55 kW Motor

Keywords :

Nomenclature

Is No load phase current

R01 Total resistance / phase referred to stator

Z01 Total impedance / phase referred to stator

X01 Total reactance / phase referred to stator

R2 Rotor resistance refer to stator

R Stator resistance

IIe Energy component of no load line current

IIm Magnetic component of no load line current

Ie Energy component of no load phase current

V0 Voltage in No Load Test

Vsc Voltage in Blocked Rotor Test

I0 Current in No Load Test

Isc Current in Blocked Rotor Test

W0 Power in No Load Test

Wsc Power in Blocked Rotor Test

Introduction

POWER electronics is one of the broadest growth areas of electrical technology. Today, electronics energy processing circuits are needed for every computer systems, every digital, industrial systems of all types, automobiles, home appliances, lamps and lighting equipment, motor controllers and just about every possible application of electricity. In recent years, the field of power electronics has experienced a large growth due to confluence of general factors. Revolutionary advances in semiconductor fabrication technology have made it possible significantly improve the voltage and current handling capability and the switching speed of power semiconductor devices, used in industrial and power system applications. At one time, the growth was pushed by energy conservation goals.

With ever increasing energy prices, every penny saved becomes a wise investment for the future, and if the saving is in the form of electrical energy, it makes even more practical sense for all types of industries. In industries, induction motor consumes around 70% of the electricity used. Collectively, their energy consumption is very high. Even a small increment in the efficiency of these motors can result in substantial savings in the long run.

In many applications constant speed operation, induction motors operate under no load or light load for prolonged periods, such as in pressing machine, conveyors, rock crushers, centrifuges, drill presses, wood saw and, some machine tools. In such applications, saving in energy can be achieved by operating the motors at low voltages while running at no load and light In many applications constant speed operation, induction motors operate under no load or light load for prolonged periods, such as in pressing machine, conveyors, rock crushers, centrifuges, drill presses, wood saw and, some machine tools. In such applications, saving in energy can be achieved by operating the motors at low voltages while running at no load and light loads. When a motor operates at full voltages at no load, core loss has a large value. Reduction in voltage increases copper loss but reduces core loss by a larger amount. Therefore, net loss is reduced. At some voltage when core loss becomes equal to copper loss; the loss has minimum value and efficiency is maximum. Any increase or decrease of voltage from this value increases the loss. Therefore, for each loading, there is an optimum value of voltage for which the loss is minimum. Energy saving is achieved by operating the induction motor at optimum voltage values.

II EFFECT OF USING OVERSIZE INDUCTION MOTOR

Power factor: The power factor of an induction motor depends upon its type, size, RPM and load. Slip ring induction motor have lower power factor than squirrel cage motors of the same size. The power factor of induction motor for different size and at different load is shown in table1. A motor running near to full load has good power factor compare to part load. Power factor deteriated very much when load below 75% of rated load.

Table: 1 Efficiency and Power Factor of different Induction Motor at different Load

Efficiency: The efficiency of three-phase induction motor varies with type size and load. It ranges from 85% to 93% in case of squirrel cage motor above 5HP. It is about 75% in case of smaller motor. The efficiency is less in case of slipring motors; slow speed motors and motors running at part loads.

Motor losses can be classified in three categories

1. Iron loss

2. Rotational losses (friction and windage)

3. Ohmic losses

Among first two are constant losses, which is not affected by motor shaft load is known as constant losses. The third is the variable losses, which varies with motor shaft load and proportional to square of fraction of rated load. The efficiency of motor is decreases faster when load is below the 75% of rated load.

Maximum demand: In industries maximum demand is very important factor. The maximum demand depends upon the type of load. i.e. whether resistive or inductive load.

In industries, maximum electricity load is contributed by induction motor and it is highly inductive load., that's why the maximum demand varies much motor, depends on shaft load of motor and efficiency because it shaft load is lower than full load of motor. The power factor and efficiency of motor decreases and maximum demand is increases. . So that proper size of the motor selection will reduce the maximum demand and cut the electric bill. Energy saving: If motor is loaded above 75% of full load, motor has high efficiency but under load condition the efficiency reduces and increases the losses.

No Load current: No load current of induction motor varies from 25% to 60% of full load current. Usually no load power factor of induction motor is around 0.15 lagging or even less. No load current of some typical induction motor shown in table 2 for 2, 4 and 6 poles. Generally as the number of poles increases in induction motor the no load current of motor also increases, and at the same time full load current of motor also increases simultaneously. This can visualize from table 2 that motor no load current varies from 25% to 40% of full load current for 2 poles motors, 30% to 50% for 4pole motors, and 35% to 60% for 6 poles motors except some small capacity motors generally has higher values.

Table: 2 Line Current of Induction Motor at different load

Load current: To estimate the load current at different loads, we can use the information given in the manufacturer catalogues

1) Efficiency of motor at 100%, 75%, 50% of full load

2) PF of motor at 100%, 75%, 50% of full load.

3) Motor full load current.

To determine the load current at 100%, 75%, 50%, of full load, following formula is used

 

No load current may be determined by either no load test of motor or from motor test certificate. This graph can be utilize for determine the shaft load for given value of motor current.

III MOTOR LOAD ESTIMATION TECHNIQUES

Operating efficiency and motor load values must be assumed or based on field measurements and motor nameplate information. The motor load is typically derived from a motor's part-load input Kw measurements as compared to its full-load value (when kW or voltage, amperage, and power factor readings are available), from a voltage compensated amperage ratio, or from an operating speed to full-load slip relationship.

Kilowatt ratio Technique

 

Also the slip technique as an indicator of load and suggests that loads be estimated by comparing a motor's true root-mean-square (rms) amperage draw against its full-load or nameplate value. Thus, the load on a motor is defined as:

Amperage ratio technique

 

While the amperage of a motor is approximately linear down to 50% load, the relationship is not directly proportional (i.e., at 50% load, current is higher than 50% of full-load current). An improved version of the amperage ratio load estimation technique makes use of a linear interpolation between a motor's full- and half-load current values. The modified equation, useful for estimating loads in the 50% to full-load range, is:

 

The current at 50% load (amps50%) can be found from manufacturer data or Motor Master.

IV AC VOLTAGE REGULATORS

Figure 1 shows the power circuit diagram of a singlephase half wave a.c voltage regulator using one thyristor in antiparallel with in diode. For three phase motors, three sets of single phase voltage controller to be used. Delaying the firing angle of thyristor T1 controls the power flow to the load. Due to the presence of diode D1, the control voltage is limited and the effective RMS output voltage can only be varied between 70.7% and 100% which is more than enough in this research (see Table no. 7). It can be observed from figure 1 that positive half cycle is not identical with negative half cycle for both voltage and current waveforms. As a result dc component is introduced in the supply and load circuits, which is undesirable. Since the power flow is control during the positive half cycle of the input cycle, this type of controller is also known as a unidirectional controller.

Figure 1 Single Phase Half Wave AC Regulator

The average value of output voltage is given by,

 

V EXPERIMENTAL STUDY

Rating of the motor: 1 Hp, 1470 rpm, 1.9A, 3 phase, class E, 50 Hz, Delta connected Induction Motor

Table 3 No Load Test

Figure 2 Block Diagram of Experimental Setup

Table 4 Blocked rotor test

From the no load and load test we have found the following equivalent circuit parameters of the induction motor,

 

Table 7 shows the required voltage for different loading condition of the above motor. For example, consider the load current 1.3A. In this load, copper loss is 146W (from table5) and the same core loss occurred at 355V (from table 4). Since the maximum efficiency only occurred at copper loss = core loss, I have selected 355V as an optimum voltage to this load

Table 5 No load loss Vs voltage

Table 6 Copper loss Vs line current

Table 7 Proposed Load Current Vs Voltage

VI CASE STUDY

Voltage control of lightly loaded induction motors should be judiciously planned based on the actual duty cycle. Case study where the energy conservation is applied in partial loaded induction motor in the organization (M/s SCM Textile spinners, Coimbatore, India) has been presented below

While carrying out the preliminary energy audit in 55 KW motor in spinning frame this motor, its load factor for one complete cycle is shown in table 8.

Table 8 Load factor for one complete cycle

Replacement of existing motor's starter by energy efficient drive (power electronics based voltage control) was recommended so as to improve the efficiency and power factor in the considerable amount.

VII Conclusion

In order to avoid harmonic current amplification due to power electronics load detuned filter circuits must be used. The demand-supply gap is expected to reach 1, 00,000MW by the year 2012 has been estimated in India. This will cause frequent power failures and cuts causing disruption in production, services and public life. Adoption of energy conservation measures is necessary to reduce effective demand. This would not only save huge investments required in building new capacity, but would also help in abatement of greenhouse gasses and other environmental pollutants

References

[1] C.Thanga Raj, S.C.Ramesh, "Role of Power Electronics in Electrical Energy Conservation", IEE (UK) Calcutta branch, International Conference Proceedings on Power, Energy and IT in Power Sector, page 242-245
[2] C.Thanga Raj, Dr. N.S.Mari muthu, "Power electronics based electrical energy conservation in industries by controlling voltage, frequency and power factor", National conference on Emerging trends in Electrical engineering and power drives at Government college of engineering, Tirunelveli
[3] Mohan, Undeland, Robbins, "Power Electronics- Converters, Applications, and design", John Wiley and Sons Publications- Third Edition.
[4] G.K.Dubay, "Fundamentals of Electrical Drives", Narosha Publications New Delhi.
[5] Donald R Wulfinghoff, "Energy efficiency manual" energy institutional press.