A Comparative Analysis Of Pulse Width Modulation Techniques For Voltage Source Inverter Fed Induction Motor Drive

R. Rajendran *  N. Devarajan **
* Assistant Professor, Department of IT, Karpagam College of Engineering, Coimbatore.
** Professor, Department of EEE, Government College of Technology, Coimbatore.

Abstract

Adjustable speed drive system requires variable voltage and frequency supply which is invariably obtained form a threephase voltage source inverter. A number of pulse width modulation schemes are used to obtain variable voltage and frequency supply form an inverter. The most widely used PWM schemes for a three phase VSI are carrier based sinusoidal PWM (SPWM) and space vector PWM (SVPWM). There is an increasing trend of using space vector PWM because of their easier digital realization and better dc bus utilization. The MATLAB/SIMULINK simulation results show the superiority of the SVPWM compared to SPWM for an adjustable induction motor drive.

Keywords :

Introduction

Power electronics converters are a family of electrical circuits which converts electrical energy from one level of voltage/current/ frequency to another using semiconductor-based electronic switch. The essential characteristic of these types of circuits is that the switches are operated only in one of two states-either fully ON or fully OFF-unlike other types of electrical circuits where the control elements are operated in a (near) linear active region. As the power electronics industry has developed, various families of power electronic converters have evolved, often linked by power level, switching devices, and topological origins [1,2].

The process of switching the electronic devices in a power electronic converter from one state to another is called modulation, and the development of optimum strategies to implement this process has been the subject of intensive international research efforts for at least 30 years. Each family of power converters has performed modulation strategies associated with it that aim to optimize the circuit operation for the target criteria most appropriate for that family. Parameters such as switching frequency, distortion, losses, harmonic generation, and speed of response are typical of the issues which must be considered when developing modulation strategies for a particular family of converters.

The conversion of DC power to three-phase AC power is exclusively performed in the switched mode. Power semiconductor switches effectuate temporary connections at high repetition rates between the two dc terminals and three phases of the ac drive motor. The actual power flow in each motor phase is controlled by the on/off ratio, dutycycle, of the respective switches. The desired sinusoidal wave form of the currents is achieved by varying the dutycycles sinusoidal with time, employing techniques of pulse width modulation (PWM). Three-phase electronic converters controlled by pulse width modulation have a wide range of applications for DC-AC power supplies and AC machine drives [3,5].

1. Voltage Source Inverter (VSI)

The three-phase two level VSI consists of six active switches. The basic topology of the inverter is shown in Figure1. The converter consists of the three legs with IGBT transistors, or (in the case of high power) GTO thyristors and free-wheeling diodes. The inverter is supplied by a voltage source composed of a diode rectifier with a C filter in the dc-link. The capacitor C is typically large enough to obtain adequately low voltage source impedance for the alternating current component in the dc-link [6,7].

Figure 1. Voltage Source Inverter

The self-commutated frequency converters generate th rectangular waveshapes that contain substantial 5 and th 7 harmonic voltages and currents. When the harmonic currents flow in the motor windings, they produce torque pulsations that are superimposed on the main driving torque. The frequency of the torque pulsation is six times that of the fundamental frequency.

For example, suppose the drive involves in a 4-pole induction motor. When the frequency of the rectangular wave is 60Hz,the synchronous speed is 1800 r/min and corresponding torque pulsation is 60x6=360Hz.On the other hand, when the frequency of 1.5Hz is applied to the stator, the synchronous speed is 45r/min and the associated torque vibration is 1.5x6=9Hz.

Torque pulsations, such as 360Hz, are damped out at moderate and high speeds, due to mechanical inetia. However, at low speeds (such as 45r/min), a 9 Hz vibration is very noticeable. Such torque fluctuations are unacceptable in some industrial applications, where fine speed control down to zero speed is required. Under these circumstances, instead of using rectangular wave shapes, the motor is driven by pulse width modulation techniques [8,9].

2. Pulse Width Modulation

In the voltage source inverter conversion of dc power to three-phase ac power is performed in the switched mode. This mode consists in power semiconductor switches are controlled in an on-off fashion. The actual power flow in each motor phase is controlled by the duty cycle of the respective switches. To obtain a suitable duty cycle for each switches technique pulse width modulation is used. Many different methods were proposed and development of it is still in progress [10-17].

The modulation method is an important part of the control structure. It should provide features like:

 

The most widely used method of pulse width modulations are carrier based. This method is also known as the sinusoidal (SPWM), triangulation, subharmonic, or suboscillation method [1,16, 18-19]. All PWM methods have specific features. However, there is not just one PWM method which satisfies all requirements in the whole operating region. Therefore, in the literature are proposed modulators, which contain from several modulation methods. For example, space vector pulse width modulation (SVPWM) [1,10,20-22], which provides the following features:

 

The content of the higher harmonics voltage (current) and electromagnetic interference generated in the inverter fed drive depends on the modulation technique.

3. Sinusoidal Pulse Width Modulation(SPWM)

Sinusoidal modulation is based on triangular carrier signals as in Figure 2. This relatively unsophisticated method employs a triangular carrier wave modulated by a sine wave and the points of intersection determine the switching points of the power devices in the inverter. However, this method is unable to make full use of the inverter's supply voltage and the asymmetrical nature of the PWM switching characteristics produces relatively high harmonic distortion in the supply. One commonly used PWM scheme is called carrier based modulation. This uses a carrier frequency usually between 10 to 20 kHz to produce positive and negative pulses of varying frequency and varying width. The pulse widths and spacing are arranged so that their weighted average produces a sine wave. Increasing the number of pulse per half cycle reduces the frequency of the output sine wave while, increasing the pulse widths increases the amplitude. In sine-triangle PWM a triangular carrier waveform of frequency fs establishes the inverter switching frequency.

Figure 2. Single phase Sine-Triangle Modulation

This is compared with three sinusoidal control voltages that comprise the three phase system. The output of the comparators produces the switching scheme used to turn particular inverter MOSFETS on or off. These three control voltages have the same frequency as the desired output sine wave which, is commonly referred to as the modulating frequency, f1. The modulation ratio is equal to mf = f1/fs. The value of mf should be an odd integer and preferably a multiple of three in order to cancel out the most dominant harmonics as these are responsible for converter losses. One limitation of the sine triangle method is that it only allows for a limited modulation index, so it doesn't fully use the DC bus. The modulation index can be increased by using distorted wave forms that contain multiples of third harmonics [23, 26]. These form zero sequence systems where the harmonics cancel out resulting in no iron losses.

The essential parameters of the SPWM are

(1)

where,

fr is the frequency of the reference.

fp is the frequency of the carrying wave.

(2)

where,

Ar : Amplitude of the reference.

Ap Amplitude of the carrying wave.

Reference signals are sinusoidal signals shifted between them of 120o and are characterized by the amplitude Ar and its frequency f.

(3)

The flux locus of SPWM is given in the Figure 3. and the harmonic content of SPWM is given in the Figure 4.

Figure 3. Flux Locus of SPWM

Figure 4. Harmonic Order of SPWM

 

4. Space Vector Pulse Width Modulation(SVPWM)

Space Vector PWM (SVPWM) is a more sophisticated technique for generating fundamental sine wave that provides a higher voltage to the motor and lower total harmonic distortion, it is also compatible for use in vector control (Field orientation) of AC motors. The aim of any modulation technique is to obtain variable output having a maximum fundamental content with minimum harmonics. Space vector PWM method is an advanced, computation intensive PWM method and possibly the best techniques for variable frequency drive applications [24-25,27]. A different approach to PWM modulation based on space vector representation of the voltages in the α-β plane. The α-β components are found by transformation. SVPWM increases output capability of SPWM without distorting line to line output voltage waveform. Because of its following superior performance characteristics, it has been finding widespread application in recent years.

 

Space Vector PWM (SVPWM) refers to a special technique of determining the switching sequence of the upper three power transistors of a three phase voltage source inverter. It has been shown to generate less harmonic distortion in the output voltages or current in the windings of the motor load. SVPWM provides more efficient use of the dc bus voltage, in comparison with the direct sinusoidal modulation technique.

The structure of a typical three-phase voltage source inverter is shown in Figure 5. The voltages Va, Vb, Vc are the output voltages applied to the windings of a motor.Q1 through Q6 are the six power transistors which are controlled by a, a', b, b', c and c' gating signals and shape , the output voltages. When an upper transistor is switched on, i.e., when a, b, and c are 1, the corresponding lower transistor is switched off, i.e., the corresponding a', b' or c' is 0. The ON and OFF states of upper transistor Q1, Q3 and Q5, or the states to evaluate the output voltage.

4.1 Switching Patterns and Basic Space Vectors

There are eight possible combinations of on and off states for the three upper power transistors. The on and off states of the lower power transistors are opposite to the upper ones, so they are determined once the states of the upper transistors are known. The eight combinations are derived output line-line and phase voltages in terms of DC supply voltage Vdc, according to (1) and (2), which are shown in  Table1.

Table 1. Combinations of VSI

The relationship between the switching variable vector [a,  b, c]T and the line to line voltage vector [Vab, Vbc, Vca ]T is given by the equ. 4

(4)

In addition, phase (line-to-line) output voltage vector [Va,Vb, Vc ]T is given by (2)

(5)

4.2 Expressions of the Space Voltages in (d-q) frame

Assuming q and d are the horizontal and vertical axes of the stator coordinate frame, the d-q transmission can transform three phase voltage vector into a vector in the d-q coordinate frame. This vector represents the spatial vector sum of the three phase voltage. The phase voltages corresponding to the eight combinations of switching patterns can be mapped into the d-q plane by the same d- q transformation. This mapping results in 6 non-zero vectors and 2 zero vectors. The non-zero vectors form the axes of a hexagonal as shown in Figure 6. The angle between any two adjacent non-zero vectors is 60o .

Figure 5. Three Phase Voltage Source Inverter

Figure 6. Basic Switching Vectors and Sensors

4.3 Approximation of output with Basic Space Vectors

The objective of the space vector PWM techniques is to approximate the reference voltage vector Vout by a combination of the eight switching patterns. One simple means of approximation is to require the average output voltage of the inverter (in small period T) to be the same as the average of Vout in the same period. This is shown in (6)  for the output voltage in the sector 0, where T4 and T6 are  the respective durations in time for which switching patterns are V4 and V6.

(6)

Where T4 +T6 ≤ T

Assuming the PWM period, Tows , is small and the change of Vout is relatively slow, from (4.4), we obtain,

(7)

Where T4 +T6 ≤ Tpwn

Equation (4.4) shows that for every PWM period, the desired reference voltage Vout can be approximated by having the power inverter in a switching pattern of V4 and V6 for T4 and T6 periods of time, respectively. Since the sum of  T4 and T6 is less than or equal to Tpwm , the inverter needs to  have a 0((000)V0 or (111) V7 ) pattern for the rest of the period as shown in Figure.7. Therefore, (8) will then become

(8)

Where,

The SVPWM for three phase induction motor drive has been simulated and the results are shown in Figure 8. This simulation results show the output line-to-line and line-toneutral fundamental rms voltage in function of modulation index.

Figure 7. Timing Diagrams

Figure 8. Simulation Results of SVPWM

Figure 8. Simulation Results of SVPWM

5. Comparison of SPWM and SVPWM

The SVPWM generates minimum harmonic distortion of the currents in the winding of 3-phae AC motor. SV Modulation also provides a more efficient use of the supply voltage in comparison with sinusoidal modulation methods [26]. In fact, with conventional sinusoidal modulation in which the sinusoidal signals are compared with a triangular carrier, we know that the locus of the reference vector is the inside of a circle with a radius of 1/2VDC In SV modulation it can be shown that the length of  each of the six vectors is 2/3VDC In steady state the  reference vector magnitude might be constant. This fact makes the SV modulation reference vector locus smaller than the hexagon described above. This locus narrows itself to the circle inscribed within the hexagon, thus having a radius of 1/√ 3 VDC . In Figure 9 the different DC reference vector loci are presented.

Figure 9. Locus Comparison of SPWM and SVPWM

Therefore, the maximum output voltage based on the Space Vector theory is 2/√3ON/OM times as large as that of the conventional sinusoidal modulation. This explains why, with SVPWM, we have a more efficient use of the supply voltage than with the sinusoidal PWM method and comparisons are given in Tables 2 and 3 applications. Its inner control system can be based on the SPWM or Space Vector PWM.

Table 2. Harmonics in output currents with SPWM & SVPWM (dB)

Table 3. Comparison of Space Vector PWM and Sinusoidal PWM

This paper presents an overview of simulation results regarding its main performance issues namely efficient use of supply voltage and harmonic distortions. These results show that there is a superior performance of SVPWM compared to the SPWM.

References

[1]. B.K .Bose, (2002) ”Modern Power Electronics and AC drives”,Prentice-Hall.
[2]. Vedam Subrahmanyam, (2005). ”Electric Drives- Concepts and Applications”, Tata McGraw-Hill.
[3]. Guy Seguir, Francis Labric, (2007). ”Coverters of Power Electronics”, Vol 4.
[4]. W. Leonhard, (1990). ”Control of Electrical Drives” Springer- Verlag, New York, Tokyo.
[5]. K. Ogata, (1990). ”Modern Control Engineering”, Prentice- Hall, New Jersey.
[6]. Mohan, Undeland, Robbins, (1989). ”Power Electronics”, Wiley, second edition.
[7]. N. Mohan, (2011)”Advanced Electric Drives”, Minneapolis,
[8]. B.D. Bedford, R.G. Hoft, R.G. et al., (1984). ”Principles of Inverter Circuits”, New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
[9]. Derek.A. Paice, (1999). ”Power Electronics Converters Harmonics”, Wiley-IEEE Press.
[10]. Tsung-Po Chen, Yen-Shin Lai, Chang-Huan Liu, (1999). ”A new space vector modulation technique for inverter control”, Power Electronics Specialists Conference, th 1999.PESC 99.30 Annual IEEE, Vol.2, No. 27, pp.777-782, June-July.
[11]. Daewoo Chung, Joohn-Sheok Kim,Seung-Ki Sul, (1998). ”Unified voltage modulation technique for realtime three-phase power conversion”, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol.34, No. 22, pp.374-380.
[12]. S. Fukuda, K. Suzuki, (1997). ”Using Harmonic distortion determining factor for harmonic evaluation of carrier-based PWM methods”, Industry Applications Conference, Thirty-Second IAS Annual Meeting, IAS'97, Conference Record of the 1997 IEEE, Vol. 2, 5-9,pp.1534- 1541, Oct.
[13]. A.M. Hava, R.J. Kerkman, T.A. Lipo, (1997). ”A high performance generalized discontinuous PWM algorithm”, Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition, APEC'97 conference Proceedings, Vol. 2,23- 27, ,pp.886-894.
[14]. A.M. Hava, R.J. Kerkman, T.A. Lipo, (1997). ”Simple analytical and graphical tools for carrier based PWM methods”, Power Electronics Specialists Conference, PESC'97 Record, 28th Annual IEEE, Vol. 222-27, pp.1462- 1471.
[15]. D.G. Holmes, (1996). ”The significance of zero space vector placemen for carrier-based PWM schemes”, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications, Vol. 32, pp.1122- 1129.
[16]. J. Holtz, (1994). ”Pulse width modulation for electronic power conversion”, Proceedings of the IEEE, Vol.82, No. 8 , pp.1194-1214.
[17]. A.M. Trzynadlowski, S.Legowski, (1994). ”Minimumloss vector PWM strategy for three-phaseinverters”, IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, Vol. 9, No. 1, pp.26- 34.
[18]. A.C. Oliveira, C.B. Jacobina, et, al. (2007) ”Improved ead-time compensation for Sinusoidal PWM inverters operating at high switching frequencies”, IEEE Transactions on Industrial Electronics, Vol.54, No 4, Aug.
[19]. P. Bowler. (1995). ”Pulse Width Modulation for Induction Motor Drive”, Proceedings of the first IEEE International Caracas Conference on Devices, Circuits and Systems, 12-14 Dec.
[20]. Peter Vas. (1992). ”Electrical machines and drives: A space-vector theory approach”, Oxford University Press.
[21]. Van der Broeck, H. Skudelny, et.al. (1986). ”Analysis and Realization of a pulse width modulator based on voltage space vectors”, Proceedings of the IEEE-IAS conference, pp.244.251.
[22]. Y. Tzou, H. Hsu. (1997). ”FPGA Realization of space vector pwm control IC for 3 phase PWM inverters”, IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, Vol.12, No.06, November.
[23]. Berrezzek Farid, Omeriri Amar, ( 2009)”A study of new techniques of controlled PWM inverters”, European journal of scientific research, Vol. 32, No.1, pp.78-88.
[24]. S. Ogasawara, H.Akagi, and A.Nabae. (1989). ”A novel PWM scheme of voltage source inverter based on space vector theory”, European Power Electronics Conference Record, Germany, pp.1197-1202.
[25]. Satean Tunyasrirut,Sompong Srilad. (2008). ”Comparison power quality of the voltage source inverter type SVPWM and SPWM technique for induction motor drive”, Proceedings of the SICE Annual Conference, pp.241-246.
[26]. G. Almer, (1991). ”A PWM current-source inverter for high quality drive: European Power Electronics Journal, Vol.1,No.1, ,pp 21-32, July.
[27]. S.R. Bowes, S.Grewal, and D. Holliday. (2001). High frequency PWM technique for two and three level single phase inverter: IEEE Proceedings-ElectricPower Applications, Vol.147, No.2, Mar.
[28].www.mathworks.com