Analysis of a Northlight Folded Plate – Whitney Method

G. Alekhya *  V. Lakshmi **
* Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, ACE Engineering College, Telangana, India.
** Associate Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, University College of Engineering, Jawaharlal Nehru Technological University, Andhra Pradesh, India.

Abstract

Modernization and urbanization world-wide have led to the increase in many high rise buildings, industries and other commercial buildings. These structures incorporate large spans with column free spacing, urging the need of roofing system that can structurally support them. Folded plates and shell structures are those types of roofing systems that can support these large span structures, structurally as well as aesthetically. Folded plate structures have gained popularity and are being used extensively in Europe, America and Asia. Folded plates have wide range of applications as roofing systems in industrial structures, ware houses, coal bunkers, cooling towers, stair cases, auditoriums, etc. The present work is to analyze a northlight folded plate of span 20 meters, height 2 meters, manually by adopting an appropriate method of analysis which takes into account the effect of distortion for longitudinal stresses and transverse moments. The Whitney method is the appropriate method to analyze the northlight folded plate which considers the end plates as cantilevers. This method of analysis is a simplified mathematical approach in which the number of simultaneous equations to be solved is reduced to two. An attempt is made to model the same using STAAD.Pro.

Keywords :

Introduction

One of the principle features of current civil engineering construction is to save structural material without affecting the durability of the structure. This highlights the use of thinwalled structures in all countries. The first and foremost terminology we should understand is stressed-skin structures. Stressed-skin structures are the type of structures that tend to carry loads primarily by direct stresses, acting in their plane due to their geometry and small flexural rigidity of the skin. This concept is mainly used in structures where maximum space and minimum weight are of primary concerns and also can be used to some stationary structures. Folded plates and shells belong to the class of stressed-skin structures.

1. Shells and Folded Plates

Shells can be defined as curved structures capable of transmitting load in more than two directions to support.

Folded plates are assemblies of flat plates rigidly connected together along their edges in such a way so as to make the structural system capable of carrying loads without the need for additional supporting beams along the mutual edges. These are also called as Hipped Plates. Each plate is assumed to act as a beam in its own plane; this assumption is justified when the ratio of the span “length” of the plate to its height “width” is large enough. But when this ratio is small, the plate behaves as a deep beam.

Folded plate structures provide an economical and aesthetically pleasing solution to the problem of roofing large areas. These structures have aroused attention in recent years because of their economic advantage and aesthetical appearance. Compared to shells these structures usually consume slightly more materials, but this disadvantage is often offset by the simpler formwork required for their construction. They offer more advantages than complex structures, such as cylindrical shells, arches and frames. Longer spans may be obtained due to inherent stiffness without an increase in material requirement.

1.1 Applications of Folded Plates


2. Objectives

A northlight folded plate roof shown in Figure 1 and Figure 2 is analyzed for the longitudinal stresses and the transverse moments for the following data [7].


Figure 1. Longitudinal View of Northlight Folded Plate

Figure 2. Cross-section of the Northlight Folded Plate

3. Analysis of the Northlight Folded Plate Using Whitney's Method

Whitney method of analysis was used for analysis of the northlight folded plate. Whitney considered the end plates of the folded plate as cantilevers. This is a simplified treatment of folded plates due to which the number of simultaneous equations to be solved is reduced by two. The Whitney method is applicable for folded plates with width and thickness of the plates and the intensity of loading uniform along the length of the plate. Mathematical computations are greatly simplified by replacing the uniform load by Fourier loading and considering only the first term of the series. The plate moments, stresses and deformations, therefore, vary as sine functions along the length, have maximum values at mid span.

4. Formulae Used

1. Plate loads were calculated by [10].

(1)
(2)

2. Additional plate loads were calculated by :

(3)

3. Additional plate loads were calculated by :

(4)
(5)

4. Resultant plate loads were calculated by :

(6)

5. Plate moments were calculated by :

(7)

6. Edge – Shear equations were established using the formula :

(8)

7. Plate deflections were calculated by :

(9)

8. Angle changes due to plate deflection were calculated by :

(10)
(11)

9. Angle changes due to loads were calculated by :

(12)

10. Angle changes due to transverse moments were calculated by :

(13)
(14)

11. The transverse moments of each plate were computed by considering the total change at each joint which is equal to zero.

(15)

From these values we arrive at the fiber stresses at the other sections, noting that their distribution along the span follows a sine curve. Then the fiber stresses are corrected by multiplying by the factor 1 π3/32. This correction is applied as only the first term of Fourier series has been used.

5. Modelling of a Northlight Folded Plate

The northlight folded plate roof structure was modeled using four noded plate elements in STAAD. Pro, and each node has six degrees of freedom. The folded plate can be modeled as a single block as a whole, but application of loads over the plate as well as the study and analysis at intermediate points is a difficult task. In order to study the performance at various critical points, folded plate was modeled as a fine division of the folded plate into finite elements. The discretization of folded plate into finite elements can be done into any number of parts. Discretization of the folded plate into elements should be such that the element of the folded plate should represent the shape of the folded plate. In the present study, the folded plate was discretized at 1 meter interval as shown in Figure 3. Details, Geometrical, Trigonometric of the Northlight Folded Plate are shown in Tables 1, 2, and 3.

Figure 3. Modelling of the Northlight Folded Plate

Table 1. Details of the Northlight folded plate

Table 2. Geometrical Properties of Northlight folded plate

Table 3. Trigonometric Properties of Northlight folded plate

6. Steps of Modeling


7. Loading on the Northlight Folded Plate Structure

Using dead load and live load, total load was calculated. From total load, ridge load acting at nodes was determined. As the analysis of a northlight folded plate was based on a mathematical approach, the ridge loads were assigned to nodes in the STAAD. Pro, directly as shown in Figures 4,5,6,7 and 8.

Figure 4. Ridge Load 327.291 kg

Figure 5. Ridge Load 1302.325 kg

Figure 6. Ridge Load 1232.091 kg

Figure 7. Ridge Load 315.632 kg

Figure 8. Deflection Profile of Northlight Folded Plate

8. Results and Discussions


8.1 Actual transverse moments

8.2 Longitudinal stresses

Longitudinal stresses are obtained by multiplying the fiber stresses obtained with a factor

Conclusions


Scope for Future Study


References

[1]. Elie A. Sehnoui, (1961). “Computer Analysis of Folded Plates”, Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
[2]. Building Digest 21, (1963). “Folded plate Roofs”, Central Building Research Institute, Roorkee,
[3]. Fredrick Mitchell Graham, (1966). “The Behavior of A Folded Plate Roof System”, Iowa State University of Science and Technology.
[4]. Rockey K.C, Evans H.R., (1976). “An Experimental and Finite Element Study of the Behavior of Folded Plate Roofs Containing Large Openings”, IABSE Publications.
[5]. Ramaswamy G.S., (1986). Design and Construction of Concrete Shell Roofs, McGraw-Hill Publishing Company, New Delhi.
[6]. Bandyopadhyay J.N., Laad P.K., (1990).“Comparative Analysis of Folded Plate Structures”. Computers & Structures, Vol. 36, No. 2, pp. 291-296.
[7]. Indian Standard code of practice for design loads(other than earthquake) for buildings and structures PART 1 DEAD LOADS – unit weights of building materials and stored materials IS: 875 (Part 1) – 1997 reaffirmed.
[8]. Indian Standard code of practice for design loads (other than earthquake) for buildings and structures PART 2 IMPOSED LOADS IS: 875 (Part 2) – 1997 reaffirmed.
[9]. Indian Standard criteria for design of reinforced concrete shell structures and folded plates IS: 2210 – 2003 reaffirmed.
10. Raamachandran J., (2013). Thin Shells Theory & Problems; Universities Press (India) Private Limited.
[11]. Arun Tejani, Parikh A.A., (2013). “Computer Aided Wind Analysis on R.C.C Folded Plate”. Indian Journal of Research, ISSN-2250-1991, Vol. 3, No. 4.
[12]. Tibu Chacko, Ramadass.S and Jayasree Ramanujan, (2013). “Parametric Study of Transverse and Longitudinal Moments of Trough Type Folded Plate Roofs Using Ansys”. American Journal of Engineering Research, e-ISSN: 2320-0847, p-ISSN: 2320-0936, Vol. 4, pp. 22-28.